Criticism of scientific and statistical research can be difficult due to the vast array of possible criticisms, some of which can render the research meaningless. The key to a good criticism lies in its potential to significantly impact our decisions and actions based on the research findings. Issues such as research fraud, causal inference, and biases can have a major impact on the validity of research. Learning statistics is crucial for understanding scientific papers, as statistics play a vital role in today’s research landscape. However, statistics can be dangerous if not used correctly, resembling a long list of special-case tests with little reason. Ultimately, the value of a statistical criticism lies in its ability to change a decision based on research outcomes.
https://gwern.net/research-criticism