The author delves into the concept of fake vs. real thinking, exploring dimensions such as map vs. world, solid vs. hollow, rote vs. new, soldier vs. scout, and dry vs. visceral. They discuss how thinking about topics like AI and philosophy can fall on different points of this spectrum, with some thoughts feeling abstract and disconnected, while others feel grounded and genuine. Examples from competitive debate and everyday life are also provided, highlighting how thinking can sometimes become detached from reality in various contexts. The discussion ultimately aims to encourage deeper, more genuine thinking, especially in the age of AI.
https://joecarlsmith.com/2025/01/28/fake-thinking-and-real-thinking/